Comparison

PLA vs PROM vs PLD

Before FPGAs dominated logic design, a single 22V10 GAL could replace a dozen discrete 74-series gates on a PCB. Understanding whether to use a PROM's fixed AND plane, a PLA's programmable AND-OR structure, or a PAL/GAL's one-time or reprogrammable array was a core skill for logic designers in the 1980s and 1990s — and it still appears in every digital electronics university syllabus and GATE paper today.

ECE, EI

Side-by-side comparison

ParameterPLAPROM
Full FormProgrammable Logic ArrayPROM: Programmable ROM | PLD: Programmable Logic Device (umbrella)
AND PlaneProgrammablePROM: Fixed (decoder — all minterms) | PAL: Programmable | GAL: Programmable
OR PlaneProgrammablePROM: Programmable | PAL: Fixed | GAL: Programmable
Product Terms per OutputShared product terms across all outputsPROM: all minterms available | PAL: fixed set per output (e.g. 8)
Typical ICPLA: custom/ASIC cellPROM: 82S100 | PAL: PAL16L8 | GAL: GAL22V10
ReprogrammableNo (mask-programmed in ASICs)PROM: OTP (one-time) | PAL16L8: OTP | GAL22V10: EEPROM, ~100 erase cycles
Speed (propagation delay)~25 ns (depends on technology)PAL16L8: ~15 ns | GAL22V10: ~5 ns
Output MacrocellNo registered outputs in basic PLAGAL22V10: OLMC (Output Logic Macrocell) — combinational or registered
Use in DesignSum-of-products logic, state machines in ASICsPROM: LUT/ROM-based logic | PAL/GAL: glue logic replacement
Modern EquivalentFPGA LUTCPLD (e.g. Xilinx XC9500) or small FPGA

Key differences

PLA has both AND and OR planes programmable — maximum flexibility, any sum-of-products function, but slower (~25 ns) and used mainly inside ASICs. PROM fixes the AND plane as a full decoder (all 2^n minterms present) and lets you program only the OR plane — every possible minterm is available, making it a universal logic element but wasteful for sparse functions. PAL (PAL16L8) fixes the OR plane and lets you program the AND plane — fast (~15 ns) but each output gets a fixed number of product terms. GAL22V10 adds EEPROM reprogrammability and an OLMC macrocell that switches between combinational and registered output, making it the most practical of the three for lab and field use.

When to use PLA

Use PROM (82S100) when implementing a truth-table-based function where the output for every minterm combination must be individually specified, such as a code converter or a character generator ROM.

When to use PROM

Use GAL22V10 when replacing multiple 74-series SSI/MSI chips with a single reprogrammable device, as its EEPROM cells allow multiple iterations during prototyping and its OLMC supports both combinational and registered outputs.

Recommendation

For university exams, choose PROM when asked about a ROM-based logic implementation — map the truth table directly to the OR plane. Choose PLA when the question asks about programmable AND and OR planes. For any practical lab replacement of glue logic, choose the GAL22V10.

Exam tip: GATE and university exams test PLA minimisation — given a Boolean function, draw the PLA diagram showing the minimum product terms in the AND plane and their connections to the OR plane outputs.

Interview tip: Interviewers at VLSI and FPGA companies ask how PLDs evolved into CPLDs and FPGAs — explain that the GAL macrocell concept scaled into the Xilinx XC9500 CPLD, which replaced discrete PALs in complex glue-logic designs.

More Digital Electronics comparisons